Once viewed as a savvy low-risk option to shore up their infield depth, the New York Yankees have officially moved on from any talks involving former All-Star Orlando Arcia — despite a late attempt by the veteran to reignite interest.
Following his release from the Atlanta Braves earlier this season, Arcia found the market surprisingly barren. Although initial reports suggested both the Yankees and Mets offered him minor-league deals, Arcia instead signed a modest $1.5 million contract with the Colorado Rockies. Now, sources say he returned to the Yankees with hopes of reviving a deal worth up to $4 million after realizing no other team was willing to come close to that figure.
According to insiders, Arcia’s camp made a “desperate plea” to re-engage the Yankees as his market collapsed. However, New York declined to revisit the offer. The team had already shifted its focus toward younger internal options and possible trade opportunities for more consistent production at third base.
Arcia, 30, made his lone All-Star appearance in 2023 but saw his performance dip significantly in 2024 and early 2025, batting just .194 before being cut loose by Atlanta. The Yankees were reportedly intrigued by his past success and versatility but were unwilling to commit more than a minor-league contract — a move Arcia initially rejected.
Now, with the Yankees eyeing more impactful names on the trade market and Arcia stuck in a reserve role with the Rockies, the situation underscores how quickly opportunities can vanish in Major League Baseball.
“It’s a tough pill to swallow,” said one executive close to the situation. “He bet on a better offer and it never came. The Yankees weren’t going to wait around.”
For New York, the decision may prove wise in hindsight. As they continue a strong push toward the postseason, the focus remains on adding proven talent that can contribute immediately — not sentimental signings or reclamation projects. For Arcia, it’s a harsh reminder that even former All-Stars can quickly find themselves on the outside looking in.
